View the entire cameo scene on YouTube. (Yep, you'll see James Stewart walking into the shipbuilding company office for his next scene.Most people, including yours truly, have assumed it was a musical instrument case, perhaps containing a horn of some kind. Lacking any proof, it was all educated guesswork. Then Hitchcock scholar Ken Mogg discovered this little tidbit on the Interwebs. It appears to have held a manual foghorn, one that looked something like this:*
Since the invention of the steam-powered foghorn in 1825, almost all foghorns have been mechanically operated. That said, even today, sailors might keep a human-powered model like this on board as an emergency backup.
As Ken notes on his November 6 blog post (you have to scroll down to find it), it is fitting that Hitch would be carrying a foghorn for his cameo in Vertigo. The San Francisco fog was as much a character in the film as the city itself. Unlike Hitch's earlier The Lodger: A Story of the London Fog (1926), which cast that city's fog in a menacing light, Vertigo plays San Francisco's mists in a minor, rather dolorous key. It sets a lonely, mysterious mood in which people mourn the loss of the past and where they may wander indefinitely like spirits. Regarding "Madeleine"'s grey suit, costume designer Edith Head recalled that Hitch wanted her "to look as if she just stepped out of the San Francisco fog – a woman of mystery and illusion." Though foghorn sounds were added to the foley mix of the 1996 restoration of the film, the original soundtrack includes the plaintive tones as well. Foghorns sound out at each end of the Golden Gate bridge, and you can hear them in the scene where "Madeleine" jumps into the bay on the San Francisco side of the bridge at Fort Point. The sounds are echoed in Bernard Herrmann's two-note motif in the music for that scene. (Watch it on YouTube here.) Hitch was prone to using musical instruments as props in his cameos. In ascending order, he carried a double-bass (Strangers on a Train), a cello (The Paradine Case) and a violin (Spellbound). In Rear Window, he showed up, naturally enough, in the composer's studio apartment, which is dominated by a baby grand piano. For a director who often compared his filmmaking approach to that of an orchestral composer, such visual juxtapositions were only natural. The foghorn he carried in Vertigo continued that pattern, while also adapting to the motifs of this particular movie. Of course, the foghorn case also reminds us that Hitch is the signal-master in his films. Yet, though he carries a seafarer's instrument, he's wearing a dark grey landlubber's suit. Hitch is not a sailor – he's the man the sailors work for. Not only does this establish his primacy in the film (after all, one of the beguiling aspects of his walk-ons is that he's both a character in the movie and a gate-crasher from behind the scenes; like a priest or shaman, he's in the film, but not of it), but it links him to the ship builder and evil mastermind Gavin Elster, who makes his appearance in the very next scene. On the other hand, you can forget everything I just said. Hitch's cameo is also just for fun. Ken pointed out the contrast of scale between the heavy machinery nearby and the tiny horn case and it also contrasts with his own stout frame. In a film that abounds with phallic imagery (see the bell tower at Mission San Juan Battista and the Coit tower that Scottie sees from his apartment window), this horn is a self-mocking little phallus, carried by a man who boasted about his celibacy to anyone who would listen. (By contrast, for his cameo in Dial M for Murder he shows up in a photo next to a Churchill cigar-chomping Anthony Lesgate (Anthony Dawson), accompanied by the voice-over "There you are, with the biggest cigar in the business.") Ken makes a further connection between this matter of the foghorn and an episode of Alfred Hitchcock Presents, "The Foghorn," which aired the same year he made Vertigo. Similarities abound, and I'll dedicate my next blog post to pointing out a few!**---------
*In his book Hitchcock as Philosopher, Robert J. Yanal suggests that it is a hunting-horn case, and theorizes that it refers to the medieval origins of the Tristan and Isolde myth in which the film's story has its origins. While he makes an interesting point (and the shape is similar), I think the connection is too abstruse and thus rather tenuous.
**For an important find like this, I want to make sure everyone gets his due credit. The question was posed initially by Frank P. Tomasulo, Ph. D. on a discussion thread on Mubi.com, and Matt Parks observed that it is likely a manual foghorn. Print this post